Smith and Jones

Good, overall. A nice little season opener.

Longer version: I do wish RTD would hand over the season kickoff to someone else for a change. I actually quite like RTD's stories (mostly for the dialogue), but he does tend to stuff too much into the 45-minutes he's got, leaving you breathless but a bit dazed and confused at the end.

The story itself is quite fun: Doctor is investigating the hospital by disguising himself as a patient is a nice touch (you'd think he'd pretend to be ... a doctor!), nice intro to Martha and her family (very compact but sufficient, nice one RTD!) and the story begins with only the "Slabs" making the thing look amateur. VERY amateur. ALARMINGLY amateur, actually. I swear I've seen -- wait, BEEN IN -- at least one fan vid with the exact same costume for a henchman!

The hospital taking off was nicely done, the moon shots were superb and the story picks up nicely from there. Ann Reid was a little charming nugget of old Avenger-y, Doctor Who-y goodness and I just loved her. Lovely to see old Roy Marsden as well, first time in Doctor Who I think though I can just dimly recall his name being bandied for the lead part itself during the Tom Baker era.

But as with any RTD script, there's a fair amount of indulgence and ridiculousness (and yes, I accept that the universe of Doctor Who has these things). The Slabs were just plain poorly done (a little digital touching-up would have made all the difference, but not explained why nobody in the post-terrorism world would have acted like they didn't see them), the whole radiation-in-the-foot schtick was overdone, the Doctor took a completely ridiculous risk (too much blood gone) to unmask Finnegan, and the idea that one over-excited x-ray device can blow up half the earth -- even when supplemented with alien tech -- is just too silly for words. The Earth would have been destroyed a hundred times over long ago if it were really that easy.

I enjoyed the further sequence where Martha finally comes aboard the TARDIS, and while it's too soon to judge her just yet the relationship looks promising. Overall, you put aside most of the silliness and enjoy it, and I did because I can remember that I'm too old now to be the target audience anymore (something I think a few old fans would do VERY well to remember!).

Having had two occasions to judge Charles Palmer's work as a director, I have to say honestly that so far he's not impressing me, but Ernie Vincze (DP) and the Visual FX team continue to amaze. Overall, a pleasing little nugget with not much substance, but offering an adequate kickstart to get things going. Let's hope the next one is more substantial (can't see how it wouldn't be).