The Girl in the Fireplace

Wednesday, 7 June 2006 - Reviewed by Paul Davies

There have only been a few times when sci-fi series have come close to perfection. The train station story in Sapphire and Steel is one, last seasons В“The Empty Child/The Doctor DancesВ” was another. Who would have thought that Steven Moffat could strike gold once more?

From the trailer last week, I was not ready for the intelligence and emotion that was contained in this story. What is more, to neatly contain it within the 45 minutes without feeling rushed makes this a classic. While there have been many who have slated RTDВ’s recent work (and really, В“Tooth and ClawВ” was damn good Saturday evening viewing, whatВ’s wrong with you?) you can still see where he fails and writers like Moffat excel.

For some, having the Doctor in a romantic lead is sacrilegious. The kiss in the TV movie had fans baying for blood. But I hope that in this instance, they can forgive the love story because it is so believable. That may be in some part because the leading lady was none other than the Doctors real life girlfriend, and boy did they have chemistry.

I dare critics to find problem with this story. It may not be for the kids, but hey, they got farting monsters last year, itВ’s the turn of the adult fans to feel that the Doctor is not only alive, but better than ever! "The Girl in the Fireplace" will stand aside all of the classic Who stories. Welcome to the Hall of Fame! Three cheers to the BBC for making Saturday evenings worth staying in for.





FILTER: - Television - Series 2/28 - Tenth Doctor