Dalek

Tuesday, 3 May 2005 - Reviewed by Peter Whiteley

On the worldwide interthingy I go by the name “dalekpete”. This was an impulse when looking for an identity almost a decade ago. I use an avatar of Abslom Daak to suggest that my electronic persona is anti-Dalek; after all who could ever have sympathy for that race of destructive killers?

Under the circumstances I awaited the episode “Dalek” with more anticipation than normal. The BBC short trailer where the chained Dalek recognised the Doctor made the hairs on the back of my neck stand up. Not for a moment was I disappointed.

I never thought that I would end the story feeling sorry for the Doctor’s greatest adversary. That the Timelord might charge around waving a gun and, in deranged way, attempt genocide seemed inconceivable; but for all we recognised the Dalek’s plight, we know he was right. This was a Dalek, the greatest killing machine known to history, and it wreaked havoc within the bunkers that housed a roughly contemporary collection of alien artefacts. However it was a pitiful, tortured being, easily out done in the despicability stakes by some of the humans.

In finding there the last remaining member of that mutant race and recognising that it was a threat the Doctor was surely doing the right thing. We all knew that Tom Baker erred in not destroying the Daleks, didn’t we? It is just that Rose has her doubts and in her few minutes with the creature she sees more than her svengali has learned in 900 years. This was the central premise of an outstanding episode.

I am sure that many will dissect the whole “Time War” aspect and wonder whether this advances the Who concept or not. There was certainly enough to satisfy aficionados of the show with references to the past. What shouldn’t be debated is that this was first rate Doctor Who and brilliant television. It was both gripping and emotional. Not just because it featured a Dalek but because it was complex in the characterisation and it altered our understanding of the Doctor and his current companion.

The Dalek was superbly visualised with the “repairs” sequence looking wonderful. An explanation of some of the finer details about the abilities of the “killing machine” only added to the fascination of the Daleks. It was voiced to perfection by Nicholas Briggs, this was an emotionless being that had to find a soul. Eccleston was outstanding, never more so when beseeching action from the other cast members in the close ups. Piper was also sound, particularly when she had the moral upper-hand. Of the non-regulars Corey Johnson was impressive, while Bruno Langley nicely underplayed his role and in joining the Doctor’s trip might be considered a companion.

While that status of Adam might be disputed, the status of this episode as a classic shouldn’t be open to question.





FILTER: - Series 1/27 - Ninth Doctor - Television